for the D’Backs getting rid of Tony Pena, one of only two Diamondbacks pitchers with a winning record so far this year. (The other is Dan Haren). And the same two words go for saying that Felipe Lopez, the only hitter who is always around .300 is available.
FIRE SALE!
I said three years ago that it looked to me that the D’Backs front office was aiming at 2009 as the year to go for the World Series. The best laid plans of mice and men etc. A lot got in the way.
The proximate cause of this year’s terrible results is injury. Ten players going down with a viral infection during spring training was a harbinger of things to come. But the real trouble started when Brandon Webb went on the DL after making only lackluster start on Opening Day. Now he is not due back until September. The DL has also been populated by Chad Tracy, Chris Snyder, Conor Jackson and, for the second year in a row, Eric Byrnes.
Then there is the issue of lack of on-field leadership — the kind supplied in 2007 by Orlando Hudson and Eric Byrnes. Hudson is now a Dodger and Byrnesie, after losing most of 2008 to injured hamstrings, was tossed under the bus last December by Bob Melvin, presumably on order from GM Josh Byrnes. Then, possibly feeling the pressure and definitely being tooo stubborn to change his batting stance, he had a horrible start, even a horrible May, which heretofore had always been his best month. And then he was hit on the left hand with a pitch and it’s bye-bye till September. No one has really taken Hudson’s and Byrnes’ places as field generals.
Bob Melvin himself lost his job after it was obvious that the team was not hitting, pitching (except for Haren) or defending. (Even the usually reliable Byrnesie sometimes looked lost in the outfield and committed two errors in one game. Unheard of before this year.) The club could have used another hitting coach (Luis Gonzalez?) But why replace a manager who succeeded with essentially the same personnel in 2007, and replace him with a young man with no managerial experience?
The answer to the first question is that when a team goes bad, it’s easier to change the manager than the team. As for Hinch, Melvin’s replacement, he was the team’s farm director and the FO has great faith in their vaunted youth movment. Hinch watched Young, Upton, Reynolds, Montero, Jackson, etc coming up. The FO hoped that Hinch would get them out of their funk. But that may not be possible at the major league level.
Disregard Jackson for a moment because of his illness. I an thinking about Young, Reynolds, and to a lesser extent (for now) Upton. Reynolds and Upton were both forced into the majors from Double A because of injuries at the major league and Triple A levels. They did a decent job under the circumstances, but now their lack of much needed minor league experience really shows. Especially with Reynolds. The FO is enamored of him because he hits homers, but his strike outs and errors demonstrate that he still needs seasoning. It is a bit too early to tell about J-Up, but he may go the same way once the pitchers get more experience of him. He is striking out a lot also — though not as much as Reynolds — and this is a disturbing trend. If he is, indeed, the next Ken Griffey, Jr., he’ll figure out how not to whiff so much, but he is still too young to be the field general the team needs if they are to be contenders. Reynolds and Upton needed some time in triple A, but after having been up in the Majors for several years, they weren’t going too be sent down this season.
But sending down might have been a good idea. Look at what happened to Valverde after he was sent down.
Young is also someone who might have benefited from another year in Triple A. He is not even at the Mendoza Line (.196 at of July 12). Another youngster on whom the FO hastily dropped a lot of money, and are keeping him up there to not admit that maybe they acted a little too quickly both in bringing him up and giving him that big contract. As a center fielder, he does not take charge the way he should, and that Is a big weakness in the team that was revealed with the departures of the agressive Hudson and Byrnes.
One only hopes that Gerardo Parra, batting a healthy .284, will not be ruined by a hasty injury-induced call-up. Pitchers are not immune and I hope Max Scherzer will not be ruined by arriving at the major league level too soon.
Some young players called up to early learn to thrive anyway. Upton MAY be such a case. We’ll see. Others stick around but never achieve their potential because coming up to soon is like trying to run before you learn to walk.
And some just don’t last in The Show for long.
The Diamondbacks look like they have too many players who came up too soon. And while we don’t now what their fates will ultimately be, we know one thing, The vaunted youth movement has failed tol become a winning team. So they are being broken up. But, in saying Lopez is available, it looks like the FO is taking it apart from the wrong end. Lopez is a veteran and the club needs veteran help.
ByrnesBlogger1
Print This Post